Public meetings / Planning Commission
February 10, 2016
59 turns, 59 with a named speaker, under 5 agenda items. The words and the names are the county clerk's.
3. For possible action - Approval of Minutes:
Commissioner King
Seconded by Commissioner Hafen
6. Commission/Director Reports:
Commissioner Borasky
stated he will in the future be getting with the Chairman to provide information on additional training for RPC members. b. Capital Improvements Plan Advisory Committee - John Koenig Next meeting will be February 18 at 2 pm. c. Director’s Report Darrell Lacy stated there will be an OML training in the next month for the RPC members that missed the previous training. d. Chairman’s Comments None.
7. Ex Parte Communications and Conflict of Interest Disclosure Statements
Commissioner Oscarson
stated he has a conflict as his mother will be speaking on item #8.
8. For Possible Action – CU-2015-000017: Public hearing, discussion, deliberation and possible action
Mr. Osborne
reviewed his staff report. Staff is recommending approval subject to the conditions of approval. Page 2 of 6
Commissioner Koenig
asked if VEA and the applicant have met, does that eliminate condition of approval #3.
Mr. Osborne
stated he believes so, but we could ask the applicant. Allen Schrimpf, Jim Scott with the Nye County Sheriff’s office.
Mr. Scott
stated the land is the Public Safety multipurpose training center. A portion of the property has been designated for the sheriff department, where a range could go. The current process is that employees have to travel to Beatty or Mercury in order to obtain training that is required annually. The maintenance on the dirt berms is cheap but effective. They will have a range master and range safety officer and approximately 5 employees per event. All controlled by the Sheriff’s office.
Commissioner Koenig
asked if this will be open anytime an officer will need it.
Mr. Scott
stated yes, it would be a scheduled event that would require a Range Master and Range Safety Officer to control the event.
Commissioner Koenig
asked if they would be shooting long rifles and pistols.
Mr. Scott
stated the long rifles would be limited to the M16 but limited to the 223 caliber.
Mr. Schrimpf
stated no 50 cal.
Commissioner Koenig
asked if the back stop is just sand.
Mr. Scott
stated sand and dirt. 44 foot base and gradually decreases to the 22 foot mark.
Commissioner King
asked how often they will be sifting and getting the lead out.
Mr. Schrimpf
stated the range in Red Rock Canyon has been there 35 years and haven’t extracted any lead out of there yet. We are looking at over 20 years before it will have to be taken out.
Commissioner King
stated he is worried about the rain runoff and the lead seeping into the drinking water.
Mr. Schrimpf
stated the lead will stay within the berm the lead won’t completely dissolve and go into the drinking water.
Mr. Scott
stated the extraction could happen yearly or every two years, the Sheriff hasn’t made a decision yet though.
Commissioner King
asked if there will be lighting.
Mr. Scott
stated at this time it hasn’t been addressed.
Commissioner Clark
asked if the Sheriff’s office will be in charge of the operation of the training at all times.
Commissioner King
asked if they are required to have an environmental impact study.
Mr. Lacy
stated no, this is not federally owned land, it is not required.
Commissioner King
stated he is still concerned with the lead.
Mr. Schrimpf
stated what lead does go in there is very minimal. Page 3 of 6
Mr. Scott
stated sifting will take place but they don’t have a time, if it will be yearly or every two years.
Commissioner Hafen
asked Mr. Sutton if there is a way to limit this to Nye County Sheriff’s department only, no outside agencies can use it.
Mr. Sutton
stated yes, although it is limited to the land and it is subject to the conditions and if they are violated it would trigger this boards ability to revoke.
Commissioner Hafen
stated we could add a condition as long as it is amenable to the applicant that only Nye County Sheriff’s deputies and officers can use the facility no matter who owns the property.
Commissioner Hafen
asked the applicant if they would be amenable to the condition.
Mr. Schrimpf
stated the only thing anticipated is if Metro comes over to help with training, to have hundreds of people there.
Mr. Lacy
stated the Sherriff’s office does conduct joint exercises with other entities. It would be a little restrictive to only Nye County deputies use it.
Commissioner Hafen
asked the applicants if they have read and understood the conditions of approval.
Commissioner Hafen
asked if they would be amenable to adding conditions of approval that there is a 20’ berm in the back and 15’ berm on the sides, and no shooting outside the berm area.
Commissioner Hafen
asked if there is a well on the property.
Mr. Lacy
stated not a drinking well but a monitoring well.
Commissioner Hafen
asked if a condition can be added to test for lead on an annual basis.
Commissioner Hafen
asked that they get a baseline before they start. Public comment opened at 6:31 pm. Rebecca Oscarson, Jeff Holley, VEA. They have concerns with the project because they have transmission lines and distribution right where they want to put the range. They would like a 30 day continuance of the application to do further research. They did make them aware that if there was damage to the lines they would be held responsible for the costs.
Mr. Scott
stated they have meet with VEA and discussed their concerns. The Sheriff is aware they would foot the bill, if it did happen it would be negligence.
Commissioner Hafen
asked if they have a time frame to have this completed.
Mr. Scott
stated they currently 30 days behind, they are required to do two firearm qualifications bi- annually according to state regulations. They are recycling a lot of the dirt, and the cost is minimal. Page 4 of 6
Commissioner Adams
asked Mrs. Oscarson what is on the table as far as mitigation.
Mrs. Oscarson
stated they would like 30 days because they would like the engineering staff to review this, if there is an outage the cost of the repair isn’t just the issue, they have an obligation to the members to always look out for their members.
Commissioner Koenig
asked if those lines are back up lines.
Commissioner Koenig
asked what would happen if those back up lines are shot.
Mrs. Oscarson
deferred to Mr. Holley who is a VEA engineer.
Commissioner Borasky
stated he met with VEA a year ago to discuss this, the Sheriff was there, two representatives for VEA also. There was some loss of communication, this could have been worked out between then and now.
Mr. Holley
stated yes redundancy is gained by that line, if you lose the redundancy you go back to where you started before the line went in.
Commissioner Koenig
stated so if that line gets shot down we would still have power, but if another line went down we would have no power.
Commissioner King
asked if there could be some sort of Kevlar sleeve that could be put on the line to protect the line.
Mr. Holley
stated he doesn’t see that being realistic.
Mr. Schrimpf
stated the lines are behind the range, there won’t be any ricochet issue.
Mr. Scott
stated one of the short meetings they had yesterday they will make sure all rounds are accounted for, if one isn’t they would coordinate with VEA. They will also include a sign at the site.
Commissioner Koenig
stated special condition #3 is in no way to allow VEA to hold you hostage and continue this project for eternity.
Commissioner Hafen
motioned to continue to the next meeting. Seconded by Commissioner Clark.
9. Future Meetings/Workshops: Discussion and Direction Concerning Items for Future
Mr. Osborne
stated staff will be bringing back the report for a study on the River plate area with recommendations.
Commissioner Koenig
would like costs included in that report. Page 5 of 6
Mr. Osborne
stated Title 6 has changed, those changes that were made may impact Title 17 zoning requirements. Staff will bring back recommendations for changes that need to be made.